Smart City Gnosys

Smart city article details

Title	Smart Cities As “Big Brother Only To The Masses”: The Limits Of Personal Privacy And Personal Surveillance
ID_Doc	49503
Authors	Galič M.
Year	2022
Published	Surveillance and Society, 20, 3
DOI	http://dx.doi.org/10.24908/ss.v20i3.15759
Abstract	Smart city projects in Europe and North America are employing a novel approach to data analysis that processes hardly any or no personal data at all. As such, these projects—at least, for the most part—escape the scope of (European) data protection law. The idea behind this new approach to smartness can be condensed in the statement: “smart cities are only Big Brother to the masses.” In other words, if the data collected within smart city projects do not identify any individuals, then there are no issues with privacy and data protection law. This problematic assumption relies on two reductive understandings of key notions in this context: that of “personal privacy” and “personal surveillance.” In this contribution, I focus on the latter and call for a broader understanding of surveillance as a set of diverse modes of social control by privacy law scholars. After all, in order to reveal the underlying dynamics of power and how these might lead to surveillance abuse—even, or especially, when surveillance is based on the processing of seemingly non-personal data—concrete surveillance practices and their logics need to be examined. For this purpose, I take the example of the Stratumseind Living Lab in the Netherlands and examine it through the lens of Foucault’s notion of security. This examination leads to two valuable insights for privacy and data protection law scholars. First of all, it strengthens the argument of contemporary group privacy scholars that a narrow focus on individual privacy and surveillance is inadequate and that the regulatory framework needs to be adapted. The second insight raises another broad issue: smart cities, which function according to the securitizing logic of surveillance, such as the Stratumseind Living Lab, are transforming public spaces into consumption spaces. Yet, the protection of privacy in public can and should serve to protect key aspects of public space—political participation and sociability—as well. © The author(s), 2022.
Author Keywords

Similar Articles

Id	Similarity	Authors	Title	Published
31226	0.912	Karim R.	Individuals’ Privacy And Data Collection In The Context Of Smart Cities: Law And Policy Review	Smart Cities to Smart Societies: Moving beyond Technology (2025)
43095	0.911	Peterson M.; Fröding B.	Privacy In A Smart City	Etikk i Praksis, 18, 1 (2024)
43101	0.893	Ziefle M.; Brell T.; Philipsen R.; Heek J.O.; Arning K.	Privacy Issues In Smart Cities: Insights Into Citizens’ Perspectives Toward Safe Mobility In Urban Environments	Big Data Analytics for Cyber-Physical Systems: Machine Learning for the Internet of Things (2019)
47883	0.888	Tariq F.; Afzaal A.; Anjum M.J.; Kanwal F.; Bashir K.; Shaheen M.	Security And Privacy Preservation In Smart Cities During Security Surveillance: A Mapping Study	Applied Computational Intelligence and Soft Computing, 2025, 1 (2025)
49750	0.885	Bernardes, MB; de Andrade, FP; Novais, P	Smart Cities, Data And Right To Privacy: A Look From The Portuguese And Brazilian Experience	PROCEEDINGS OF THE 11TH INTERNATIONAL CONFERENCE ON THEORY AND PRACTICE OF ELECTRONIC GOVERNANCE (ICEGOV2018) (2018)
6	0.883	Purandare U.; Parkar K.	"Eyes And Ears": Surveillance In The Indian Smart City	Handbook of Smart Cities (2021)
43071	0.882	Fabrègue B.F.G.; Bogoni A.	Privacy And Security Concerns In The Smart City	Smart Cities, 6, 1 (2023)
5174	0.879	El Majdoubi D.; El Bakkali H.	A Survey Of Major Data Privacy Laws, Languages And Approaches In Smart Cities Environments	ACM International Conference Proceeding Series (2019)
44527	0.879	Jin Y.; Wang Y.	Reassessing Smart City Development And Personal Data Protection: A Regulatory Framework	International Review of Economics and Finance, 99 (2025)
43066	0.879	Momen N.	Privacy And Ethics In A Smart City: Towards Attaining Digital Sovereignty	Advanced Sciences and Technologies for Security Applications (2023)