Smart City Gnosys
Smart city article details
| Title | Urban Digital Twins And Metaverses Towards City Multiplicities: Uniting Or Dividing Urban Experiences? |
|---|---|
| ID_Doc | 59924 |
| Authors | Argota Sánchez-Vaquerizo J. |
| Year | 2025 |
| Published | Ethics and Information Technology, 27, 1 |
| DOI | http://dx.doi.org/10.1007/s10676-024-09812-3 |
| Abstract | Urban Digital Twins (UDTs) have become the new buzzword for researchers, planners, policymakers, and industry experts when it comes to designing, planning, and managing sustainable and efficient cities. It encapsulates the last iteration of the technocratic and ultra-efficient, post-modernist vision of smart cities. However, while more applications branded as UDTs appear around the world, its conceptualization remains ambiguous. Beyond being technically prescriptive about what UDTs are, this article focuses on their aspects of interaction and operationalization in connection to people in cities, and how enhanced by metaverse ideas they can deepen societal divides by offering divergent urban experiences based on different stakeholder preferences. Therefore, firstly this article repositions the term UDTs by comparing existing concrete and located applications that have a focus on interaction and participation, including some that may be closer to the concept of UDT than is commonly assumed. Based on the components found separately in the different studied cases, it is possible to hypothesize about possible future, more advanced realizations of UDTs. This enables us to contrast their positive and negative societal impacts. While the development of new immersive interactive digital worlds can improve planning using collective knowledge for more inclusive and diverse cities, they pose significant risks not only the common ones regarding privacy, transparency, or fairness, but also social fragmentation based on urban digital multiplicities. The potential benefits and challenges of integrating this multiplicity of UDTs into participatory urban governance emphasize the need for human-centric approaches to promote socio-technical frameworks able to mitigate risks as social division. © The Author(s) 2024. |
| Author Keywords | Collective intelligence; Human-centric planning; Metaverse; Participation; Social divisiveness; Urban Digital Twins |
Similar Articles
| Id | Similarity | Authors | Title | Published |
|---|---|---|---|---|
32068  | 0.928 | Qanazi S.; Leclerc E.; Bosredon P. | Integrating Social Dimensions Into Urban Digital Twins: A Review And Proposed Framework For Social Digital Twins | Smart Cities, 8, 1 (2025) |
| 60167 | 0.928 | Charitonidou M. | Urban Scale Digital Twins In Data-Driven Society: Challenging Digital Universalism In Urban Planning Decision-Making | International Journal of Architectural Computing, 20, 2 (2022) |
| 41346 | 0.926 | Nochta T.; Oti-Sarpong K. | Participation Matters: The Social Construction Of Digital Twins For Cities | Environment and Planning B: Urban Analytics and City Science (2024) |
| 56880 | 0.921 | Yossef Ravid B.; Aharon-Gutman M. | The Social Digital Twin:The Social Turn In The Field Of Smart Cities | Environment and Planning B: Urban Analytics and City Science, 50, 6 (2023) |
| 4227 | 0.92 | Mazzetto S. | A Review Of Urban Digital Twins Integration, Challenges, And Future Directions In Smart City Development | Sustainability (Switzerland), 16, 19 (2024) |
| 56059 | 0.918 | Allam Z.; Sharifi A.; Bibri S.E.; Jones D.S.; Krogstie J. | The Metaverse As A Virtual Form Of Smart Cities: Opportunities And Challenges For Environmental, Economic, And Social Sustainability In Urban Futures | Smart Cities, 5, 3 (2022) |
| 10666 | 0.915 | Haraguchi M.; Funahashi T.; Biljecki F. | Assessing Governance Implications Of City Digital Twin Technology: A Maturity Model Approach | Technological Forecasting and Social Change, 204 (2024) |
| 20247 | 0.914 | Zainab H.E.; Bawanay N.Z. | Digital Twin, Metaverse And Smart Cities In A Race To The Future | 2023 24th International Arab Conference on Information Technology, ACIT 2023 (2023) |
| 51650 | 0.912 | Diaz-Sarachaga J.M. | Smart Urban Governance: The Baseline For Governing Future Cities | Communications in Computer and Information Science, 2394 CCIS (2025) |
| 59925 | 0.912 | Dembski, F; Wössner, U; Letzgus, M; Ruddat, M; Yamu, C | Urban Digital Twins For Smart Cities And Citizens: The Case Study Of Herrenberg, Germany | SUSTAINABILITY, 12, 6 (2020) |