Smart City Gnosys

Smart city article details

Title	Unboxing The Blackbox Of Human-Centric And Inclusive Smart City Initiatives: A Theory Based Evaluation Framework
ID_Doc	59398
Authors	Shin J.E.; Joe M.; Kim E.; Kang N.; Lee J.; Lee S.-W.
Year	2024
Published	Asian Journal of Technology Innovation
DOI	http://dx.doi.org/10.1080/19761597.2024.2367762
Abstract	The concept of smart cities has evolved from a technology and data-driven approach to a more human-centred and inclusive model. This paper explores the shift in smart city development towards a focus on human-centric and inclusive solutions while suggesting a novel evaluation framework for these smart city initiatives. Through a comprehensive literature review, the study identifies key challenges in evaluating smart city initiatives including the lack of standardized evaluation frameworks, limited focus on social and environmental outcomes, and the need for citizen participation. To address these challenges, the paper proposes a theoretical framework grounded in a realist evaluation approach. This framework incorporates a Theory of Change (ToC) that outlines the causal pathways and contextual factors underlying smart city initiatives. The proposed framework is designed to guide the evaluation of smart city initiatives by providing specific evaluation criteria and sub-criteria that are aligned with the objectives of inclusive and sustainable urban development. By highlighting the importance of human-centric and inclusive approaches and providing a practical evaluation framework, the paper aims to contribute to the ongoing discourse on smart cities and their evaluation.
Author Keywords	generative causation; inclusive smart city; realist approach; Smart city evaluation; theory of change

Similar Articles

Id	Similarity	Authors	Title	Published
24617	0.919	Hodson E.; Vainio T.; Sayún M.N.; Tomitsch M.; Jones A.; Jalonen M.; Börütecene A.; Hasan M.T.; Paraschivoiu I.; Wolff A.; Yavo-Ayalon S.; Yli-Kauhaluoma S.; Young G.W.	Evaluating Social Impact Of Smart City Technologies And Services: Methods, Challenges, Future Directions	Multimodal Technologies and Interaction, 7, 3 (2023)
56436	0.918	Ateeq A.; Milhem M.; Alzoraiki M.; Beshr B.; Almeer S.; Ali S.A.	The Rise Of Smart Cities: Integrating Technology For Sustainable Urban Development	Studies in Systems, Decision and Control, 568 (2025)
1155	0.911	Shi F.; Shi W.	A Critical Review Of Smart City Frameworks: New Criteria To Consider When Building Smart City Framework	ISPRS International Journal of Geo-Information, 12, 9 (2023)
49752	0.907	Kolotouchkina O.; Ripoll González L.; Belabas W.	Smart Cities, Digital Inequalities, And The Challenge Of Inclusion	Smart Cities, 7, 6 (2024)
59428	0.904	Yigitcanlar, T; Kamruzzaman, M; Buys, L; Ioppolo, G; Sabatini-Marques, J; da Costa, EM; Yun, JJ	Understanding 'Smart Cities': Intertwining Development Drivers With Desired Outcomes In A Multidimensional Framework	CITIES, 81 (2018)
50058	0.901	Lee J.; Babcock J.; Pham T.S.; Bui T.H.; Kang M.	Smart City As A Social Transition Towards Inclusive Development Through Technology: A Tale Of Four Smart Cities	International Journal of Urban Sciences, 27, S1 (2023)
57848	0.9	Simonofski A.; Van Den Storme S.; Meers H.	Towards A Holistic Evaluation Of Citizen Participation In Smart Cities	ACM International Conference Proceeding Series (2020)
50243	0.9	Shamsuzzoha, A; Nieminen, J; Piya, S; Rutledge, K	Smart City For Sustainable Environment: A Comparison Of Participatory Strategies From Helsinki, Singapore And London	CITIES, 114 (2021)
34541	0.897	Lee S.; Park I.K.	Key Themes And Conceptual Frameworks For A Smart-Inclusive City: A Scoping Review	Journal of Planning Literature (2025)
59003	0.896	Han, ZY; Ja'afar, NH; Abd Malek, MI; Lyu, Y	Trends, Obstacles, And Opportunities For Smart Cities In Urban Space: A Systematic Literature Review	TOWN AND REGIONAL PLANNING, 86 (2025)