Smart City Gnosys

Smart city article details

Title	Systematic Literature Review Of The Smart City Maturity Model
ID_Doc	54314
Authors	Aljowder T.; Ali M.; Kurnia S.
Year	2019
Published	2019 International Conference on Innovation and Intelligence for Informatics, Computing, and Technologies, 3ICT 2019
DOI	http://dx.doi.org/10.1109/3ICT.2019.8910321
Abstract	While there has been an increasing number of studies on smart cities, there are still issues in assessment and governance of these cities. This study aims to analyze and provide insights into the research done in smart city maturity models by conducting a systemically review of related literature. The study discusses and analyzes 22 maturity frameworks from the peer-reviewed articles. The discussion also included the alignment of the smart city to the United Nations sustainable development goals. The analysis shows that there is an increased emphasis on the development of maturity models over the years 2011-2018 However, only 9 out of the 22 models were comprehensive, other models were focused on specific aspects such as citizens, data and IoT. In addition, 50% of the models from the literature included components related to technology but most of the models lacked assessment of the environmental aspects. This review indicates the need for a comprehensive smart cities' maturity model to assess the cities in their smartness transformation.
Author Keywords	Literature review; Maturity frameworks; Maturity models; Smart cities

Similar Articles

Id	Similarity	Authors	Title	Published
45218	0.917	Myeong S.; Park J.; Lee M.	Research Models And Methodologies On The Smart City: A Systematic Literature Review	Sustainability (Switzerland), 14, 3 (2022)
19579	0.915	Aljowder T.; Ali M.; Kurnia S.	Development Of A Maturity Model For Assessing Smart Cities: A Focus Area Maturity Model	Smart Cities, 6, 4 (2023)
8374	0.907	Topuz E.; Coşkun Ö.; Tütek Y.; Çakır Ö.; Temur G.T.; Sivri Ç.	An Innovative Digital Maturity Assessment Model For Smart Cities	Lecture Notes in Operations Research, Part F3778 (2022)
50465	0.906	Zhao, F; Fashola, OI; Olarewaju, TI; Onwumere, I	Smart City Research: A Holistic And State-Of-The-Art Literature Review	CITIES, 119 (2021)
50598	0.904	Arief A.; Sensuse D.I.; Mursanto P.	Smart City'S Trends, Architectures, Components, And Challenges: A Systematic Review And Building An Initial Model For Indonesia	Engineering and Applied Science Research, 49, 2 (2022)
4201	0.902	Kumar P.; Pal A.; Hsieh S.-H.	A Review Of Smart City Maturity Assessment Models	Lecture Notes in Civil Engineering, 358 LNCE (2023)
3842	0.9	Budna K.	A Proposal For A Sustainable And Smart Mobility Maturity Model Based On Smart City Maturity Models	Lecture Notes in Networks and Systems, 1155 LNNS (2024)
55620	0.898	Ruhlandt, RWS	The Governance Of Smart Cities: A Systematic Literature Review	CITIES, 81 (2018)
5447	0.898	Karal F.S.; Soyer A.	A Systematic Literature Review: Setting A Basis For Smart And Sustainable City Performance Measurement	Sustainable Development, 32, 1 (2024)
4717	0.898	Koekemoer S.; Von Solms R.	A Smart City Maturity Assessment Model For South African Municipalities	2022 IST-Africa Conference, IST-Africa 2022 (2022)