Smart City Gnosys

Smart city article details

Title	Smartocracy: Context Entanglement Of The Smart City Idea And Bureaucracy In Russia
ID_Doc	51881
Authors	Khodachek I.; Aleksandrov E.; Nazarova N.; Grossi G.; Bourmistrov A.
Year	2023
Published	Organization Studies, 44, 10
DOI	http://dx.doi.org/10.1177/01708406221123373
Abstract	This paper explores how the smart city idea unfolds in the bureaucratic context. Applying a qualitative approach and the Scandinavian stream of translation theory, we investigate the case of cities' 'smartification' in Russia during 2017-2020. Tracking mechanisms and outcomes of translation, we see the encounter of the smart city idea and bureaucracy as context entanglement, with smartocracy as an epilogue. Context entanglement refers to the mutual co-translation of the smart city idea and bureaucracy by means of formal and informal mechanisms, implying that what happens with bureaucracy or the smart city cannot be fully described without considering what happens with the other. Smart city vagueness and complexity appear to be both strengths and weaknesses that can be compensated for by bureaucracy as the smart city assemblage point. Smartocracy appears as a new way to organize cities whereby bureaucracy deals with smart city creatively: it keeps the core of bureaucracy while simultaneously reinforcing it and isolating some complex idea elements for later translation. This approach helps keep bureaucracy as a rational form of city modernization while maintaining smart cities' promise to improve urban futures.
Author Keywords	bureaucracy; context entanglement; Russia; smart city; smartocracy; translation

Similar Articles

Id	Similarity	Authors	Title	Published
11916	0.876	Mittal H.; Kandathil G.; Mathur N.	Beyond The Technology-Centric And Citizen-Centric Binary: Ontological Politics Of Organizing In Translation Of The Smart City Discourse In India	Organization, 31, 4 (2024)
36912	0.874	Zaman S.; Hertweck C.	Methods For Uncovering Discourses That Shape The Urban Imaginary In Helsinki'S Smart City	Frontiers in Sustainable Cities, 4 (2022)
62198	0.872	Turgel I.; Bozhko L.; Ulyanova E.	‘Smart City’ Concept In Digital Economics: Practice Of Russia And Kazakhstan	International Journal of Economic Policy in Emerging Economies, 16, 2-4 (2022)
49886	0.872	Visvizi A.; Godlewska-Majkowska H.	Smart Cities: Lock-In, Path-Dependence And Non-Linearity Of Digitalization And Smartification	Smart Cities: Lock-in, Path-dependence and Non-linearity of Digitalization and Smartification (2024)
43354	0.87	Gabrys J.	Programming Environments: Environmentality And Citizen Sensing In The Smart City	Smart Urbanism: Utopian vision or false dawn? (2015)
37767	0.87	Sadowski, J; Maalsen, S	Modes Of Making Smart Cities: Or, Practices Of Variegated Smart Urbanism	TELEMATICS AND INFORMATICS, 55 (2020)
61296	0.87	Trunova O.; Khodachek I.; Khodachek A.	Visualising And Calculating The Smart City: A Dialogue Perspective	Journal of Public Budgeting, Accounting and Financial Management, 34, 5 (2022)
13140	0.87	Lekkas C.-K.; Souitaris V.	Bureaucracy Meets Digital Reality: The Unfolding Of Urban Platforms In European Municipal Governments	Organization Studies, 44, 10 (2023)
27303	0.868	Costales E.; Zeyen A.	From Social Interaction To Societal Discourse: An Ordonomic Analysis Of The Smart City	Cities, 161 (2025)
56791	0.868	Volkov S.K.; Morozova I.A.; Gladkaya E.A.; Akimova O.E.; Kuzlaeva I.M.	The Smart City Concept In Russia: Problems Of Transition And Humanization Of The Digital Environment From The Perspective Of The Quality Of Public Administration	International Journal for Quality Research, 17, 2 (2023)