Smart City Gnosys

Smart city article details

Title	Problematizing Data-Driven Urban Practices: Insights From Five Dutch 'Smart Cities'
ID_Doc	43276
Authors	Bunders, DJ; Varró, K
Year	2019
Published	CITIES, 93
DOI	http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.cities.2019.05.004
Abstract	Recently, the concept of the smart city has gained growing popularity. As cities worldwide have set the aim to harness digital technologies to their development, increasing focus came to lie on the potential challenges and concerns related to data-driven urban practices. In the existing literature, these challenges and concerns have been dominantly approached from a pragmatic approach based on the a priori assumed 'goodness' of the smart city; for a small group of critics, the very notion of the smart city is questionable. This paper takes the middleway by interrogating how municipal and civil society stakeholders problematize the challenges and concerns related to data-driven practices in five Dutch cities, and how they act on these concerns in practice. The lens of problematization posits that the ways of problematizing data-driven practices contribute to their actual enactment, and that this is an inherently political process. The case study shows that stakeholders do not only perceive practical challenges but are widely aware of and are (partly) pro-actively engaging with perceived normativeethical and societal concerns, leading to different (sometimes inter-related) technological, legal/political, organizational, informative and participative strategies. Nonetheless, the explicit contestation of smart city policies through these strategies remains limited in scope. The paper argues that more research is needed to uncover the structural-institutional dynamics that facilitate and/or prevent the repoliticization of smart city projects.
Author Keywords	Smart cities; Big data; Urban policy; Policy problematization; Smart city-related concerns

Similar Articles

Id	Similarity	Authors	Title	Published
33167	0.919	Esposito G.; Terlizzi A.; Guarino M.; Crutzen N.	Interpreting Digital Governance At The Municipal Level: Evidence From Smart City Projects In Belgium	International Review of Administrative Sciences, 90, 2 (2024)
55113	0.916	Enlund D.; Harrison K.	The Complexities Of Smartification: Exploring Horizontal Tensions In Smart City Governance	Urban Studies (2024)
28179	0.916	Meijer, A; Bolívar, MPR	Governing The Smart City: A Review Of The Literature On Smart Urban Governance	INTERNATIONAL REVIEW OF ADMINISTRATIVE SCIENCES, 82, 2 (2016)
49496	0.914	Mondschein, J; Clark-Ginsberg, A; Kuehn, A	Smart Cities As Large Technological Systems: Overcoming Organizational Challenges In Smart Cities Through Collective Action	SUSTAINABLE CITIES AND SOCIETY, 67 (2021)
25507	0.914	Anthony, B Jr	Exploring Data Driven Initiatives For Smart City Development: Empirical Evidence From Techno-Stakeholders' Perspective	URBAN RESEARCH & PRACTICE, 15, 4 (2022)
10647	0.913	Bozkurt Y.; Rossmann A.; Pervez Z.; Ramzan N.	Assessing Data Governance Models For Smart Cities: Benchmarking Data Governance Models On The Basis Of European Urban Requirements	Sustainable Cities and Society, 130 (2025)
20333	0.912	Nochta T.; Lemanski C.; Wan L.; Parlikad A.K.; Schooling J.M.; Jin Y.	Digitalisation For Smarter Cities: Moving From A Static To A Dynamic View	Proceedings of the Institution of Civil Engineers: Smart Infrastructure and Construction, 171, 4 (2019)
49398	0.91	Durga K.S.; Murty A.V.N.; Kesalu S.V.; Chandra D.; Mishra P.; Upadhyay M.; Rao A.V.S.S.R.	Smart Cities And Social Equity: A Data Science Perspective On Urban Development	Journal of Applied Bioanalysis, 11, 3 (2025)
50261	0.91	Mora L.; Gerli P.; Ardito L.; Messeni Petruzzelli A.	Smart City Governance From An Innovation Management Perspective: Theoretical Framing, Review Of Current Practices, And Future Research Agenda	Technovation, 123 (2023)
28177	0.909	Edelenbos J.; Hirzalla F.; van Zoonen L.; van Dalen J.; Bouma G.; Slob A.; Woestenburg A.	Governing The Complexity Of Smart Data Cities: Setting A Research Agenda	Public Administration and Information Technology, 24 (2018)